The Shift (Philosophy)

Why 90% of Your Partnership Emails Are Being Ignored

Date

Sep 1, 2025

Author

Matt Astarita

Let’s be real for a second. You’ve been there.

You spent two hours researching a partner. You mapped out the tech stack overlap. You even found that obscure podcast interview the VP of Sales did three years ago just to find a hook. You typed up what you thought was a masterpiece of an email, hit send, and then…

Crickets.

A week later? You send the polite "just bumping this" follow-up. Still nothing.

It’s not just you. It’s the entire ecosystem.

The hard truth is that B2B outreach is hitting a wall. Open rates are plummeting, and if you’re getting a reply rate above 1%, you’re practically a wizard. But before you rewrite your email templates for the tenth time, you need to understand why this is happening. It’s usually not because your writing is bad. It’s because the system is broken.

Here is why your partnership emails are collecting dust—and what you actually need to do to get a response.

 

1. You smell like a template

 Partnership managers at top SaaS companies are inundated. They have developed a sixth sense for automation.

If your email starts with "I hope this email finds you well" or "I’d love to pick your brain," you are immediately categorized as "Noise." It doesn't matter if you wrote it by hand; if it reads like a sequence, it gets treated like one.

The Fix: drop the pleasantries. Nobody cares if the email "finds them well." They care about their Q3 goals. Start with context that hurts.

  • Don’t say: "I want to explore synergies."

  • Do say: "I saw you just launched the HubSpot integration. We share about 50 customers who are complaining that they can’t sync that data to us yet."

 

2. You’re proposing on the first date

 This is the most common mistake I see. You send a cold email that asks for 30 minutes of time, attaches a slide deck, and suggests a referral commission structure.

Slow down.

Asking a stranger for 30 minutes is a big ask. You are asking them to give up their most scarce resource—time—before you’ve proven you aren’t a waste of it.

The Fix: Lower the stakes. Stop asking for a meeting. Ask for validation. Instead of "Can we chat on Tuesday?", try: "Is an integration in the HR space even a priority for you right now, or should I wait until next quarter?"

It gives them an out, which ironically makes them more likely to reply.

 

3. The "Info@" Abyss

 If you are sending emails to partners@company.com, you might as well print your proposal and shred it.

Those inboxes are rarely checked by decision-makers. They are manned by support staff or junior reps who are trained to block gatecrashers, not open gates. Even if you guess the Head of Partnership’s direct email, you’re gambling on timing. You might be the perfect partner, but if they are in the middle of a fire drill or a product launch, you’re invisible.

 

4. The real problem: You’re guessing

 The fundamental flaw with cold outreach is that it’s a guessing game. You are "spraying and praying," hoping that your email lands in the inbox of someone who happens to be thinking about your specific category right now.

That is a lottery ticket, not a strategy.

The most effective partnerships don't come from convincing someone to care. They come from finding the people who already care.

 

Stop Hunting. Start Matching.

 The cold email era is dying because it’s inefficient. The sender hates sending them; the receiver hates getting them.

This is exactly why we built PartnerMatch.ai. We got tired of the noise.

We operate on a "Double Opt-In" system—basically, the way modern dating apps work, but for B2B revenue.

  1. You post your intent: "I have an HR tool. I need Payroll partners."

  2. They post their intent: "I am a Payroll provider. I need HR integrations."

  3. The Match: We only introduce you when both sides fit.

When you message a match on our platform, they actually reply. Not because your subject line was witty, but because they were already looking for you.

If you have to send cold emails, make them short, relevant, and painfully specific.

But if you want to stop shouting into the void?

Stop guessing who wants to talk to you, and start looking for the partners who have already raised their hands.

Stop flying blind. Turn on the lights.

Join the network where data is free and growth is automated.

Stop flying blind. Turn on the lights.

Join the network where data is free and growth is automated.

Stop flying blind. Turn on the lights.

Join the network where data is free and growth is automated.